psychiatry for lawyers .com
  home page The Author Reports contact us  
 
Introductory
 classification

 definition

 FAQs

 glossary

 psychiatric injury- medical

 treatment: general aspects

Medicolegal
 assessment process

 diagnosis & function

 causation

 forensic

 Mental Health Act

 psychiatric negligence

 psychiatric negligence 2

 psychiatric injury- legal

 psychiatric injury- legal 2

 capacity



Dr David Gill Dr Gill is an NHS Consultant, with a medico-legal practice.
CBT & psychotherapy

print view

CBT stands for "cognitive-behavioural psychotherapy". It is very often recommended in medcolegal reports. It is a form of ģtalking treatmentī which is currently popular because
  • it is understandable in common sense terms (unlike psychoanalytic therapies)
  • it has been shown in randomised controlled trials to work more effectively than placebo (dummy) treatments- and is therefor "evidence-based".
It consists of:
  • a cognitive component (Latin cogito, I think), where the patient identifies and learns to modify unhelpful thought patterns, such as negative thinking, black and white thinking, etc.
  • plus a behavioural component, where a patient sets themselves targets (e.g. an agoraphobic gradually learning to go out more).
CBT will typically consist of 6-12 1-hour sessions with a therapist, usually either a psychiatrist, psychologist or nurse (though any professional can train in CBT).

CBT is the ģflavour of the monthī, so that there have even been suggestions of a mass programme of recruiting 10,000 therapists to tackle psychological problems on a population basis- though the sudden stringency in NHS funding may be the reason the programme has yet to get underway..

CBT: CURRENT PERSPECTIVES One hopes that CBT will not be wrongfully rejected if the great expectations placed upon it are- as seems only too possible- not fully substantiated in practice.

It is probably the treatment of choice for mild cases of anxiety. But in complex cases, it is best seen as part of the treatment package, not the sole treatment offered.

If used alone in complex cases, with physical, personal and social problems antedating the current episode of illness, large sustained effects are unlikely from the CBT alone.

In everyday clinical practice, treatment effects of CBT are typically modest, ameliorating symptoms to some extent but making little difference to function. Multidisciplinary care is needed for these patients to progress.

CBT AND REHABILITATION On its own, CBT may produce improvement in symptoms. However, symptomatic improvement may not necessarily be accompanied by improvement in function.

Therefore, especially in the medicolegal scenting, there will be increasing reluctance to pay for CBT to be carried out in isolation. This will probably be positive, however, because CBT is ideally suited to be carried forward into graduated programmes of return to work (GRTWP). Those funding CBT programs in the future may therefore in the future insist that it be integrated into rehabilitation.

Mental Disorders
 alcohol misuse

 anxiety & PTSD

 CBT & psychotherapy

 dementia & delirium

 depression

 drug misuse

 drug treatment

 eating disorders

 ECT & psychosurgery

 medication

 mental health services

 old age psychiatry

 paranoid states

 personality disorder

 prognosis

 psychological treatment

 schizophrenia

 sexual problems

 suicide and self-harm

 women's health

 
       
       
psychiatryforlawyers.com   home  feedback  the author  reports  training  contact    
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER This website is provided in good faith for general information only, based on Dr Gill's understanding of psychiatry in the UK. It does not represent the views of any organisation with which he has a relationship. It is not to be taken as advice or opinion on any specific case or issue whatsoever. In particular, material provided about the method of assessment in medicolegal cases or about any other matters is not to be taken out of context. Opinion expressed by Dr. Gill in an individual medicolegal case and method of assessment may adhere to or depart from the material on this website entirely according to his professional judgement. Nothing on this website forms part of his terms and conditions for medicolegal work, let alone part of his reports. Nor does Dr. Gill holds himself out as an authority on these matters. Other views undoubtedly exist on most if not all matters covered, which may be just as valid as his. No liability is accepted for any use of this website, or for any error or omission. By using the site, you agree to these terms. The text partly derives from Outline of Psychiatry, a textbook originated by Dr Jenny Barroclough, later prepared jointly, and the most recent edition by Dr Gill.


 
Copyright © Dr David Gill. All rights reserved.